I went to their new office on Canal street and met some dude who claims to be David’s brother. He was rude and disrespectful, kept reducing the price every time I agreed to a new price.

I was looking for a place to sell some jewelry I had. David was amazing told me what everything was and how much I could get for it. He took time to go back and fourth with me on one thing I wasn’t sure about and was completely honest. I had a great experience and seriously suggest hitting this place up for all your needs.

Fast, reliable, friendly service.... I will most definitely be back.

This tiny little shop that youll miss if you blink has to be the best selling experience Ive ever had. My husband and I both inherited coins, jewelry, etc. that we just didnt need, and somehow discovered this gem of a place. David and his father, who work together, have now become like family to us. You feel like youre dealing with people who really care, want to help you out, give you the absolute best price, and you dont feel as if youre dealing with a used car salesman, like you might if you went anywhere else. My husband had first taken his coins to some fancy place uptown, where they tried to scam him by telling him his coins werent worth anything, yet wanted to buy them at the low-ball price. He then discovered NYCity Buyers and was thrilled with his experience. Untra-fair pricing, wonderful customer service. I now sell my stuff to them. (Although Id read you get more $ on eBay selling coins, after eBay fees, etc., I got way more $ from NYCity Buyers, without the hassle of shipping, mailing insurance, etc.)I cant say enough good things about these people! You almost feel guilty when leaving, theyve taken such good care of you in so many ways! I look forward to doing business with them over and over again in the future (Time to clean out my safe deposit box of grandmas outdated jewelry?). THE ABSOLUTE #1 BEST. A+++

If you want fair and honest prices this is definitely the place to go. After searching many locations for the best quote to sell my gold jewelry I got the most reasonable price here. Thank you to the owners for their great advice and knowledge insight.

Stopped in to buy some coins. Older gentleman was very rude. He offered to sell 90% silver coins at $10 above spot price. I asked if he can do better on the price and he just took coins away and went back on his computer and told me I do not collect coins. Not a way to treat a first time customer. I do not reccommend this place.

My wife and had some old estate jewelry that her grandmother left her. They went through all the items and found a vintage Tiffany and Co diamond platinum ring we had no idea about. We got paid more for that item then we expected for everything. Their honesty and knowledge is highly recommended. Thanks guys

I needed to have some links taken out of my new watch. David was very helpful & the price was extremely reasonable. Great service!

Great quality watches and other fine jewelry. Friendly staff and best of all fair prices.

David is one of the most knowledgeable and honest people I encountered shopping for a watch. Highly recommended NYCity Buyers!

Very pleased with my experience, I shopped around a bunch of old estate gold jewelry I had over the years. When I visited nycity buyers, I got a better understanding of what I had they took the time to explain the prices and show the weights the other places didn’t. They offered closer to what I expected then any other place. Very happy I did business here, would definitely come back !!

After visiting a few other buyers, NYCity Buyers definitely offered the most and best service. I have been looking for a reliable coin dealer I can trust. Highly recommend if your looking to buy or sell gold or silver jewelry and coins.

One of the best gold selling experience. Sold old gold ring with diamonds. They paid for both gold and diamonds. Amazing experience.

!!BEWARE!! Ripoff... I went in to find out the price of a few gold coins and pieces of jewelry and they tried to rip me off! I weighed the pieces at home first and took them to another jeweler to weigh just to make sure and they told me that the total weight was 7 grams lighter than the actual!! STAY AWAY!! Their scales are rigged!

I stopped in at NYCity Buyers for an appraisal on some old jewelry again. And I was very impressed with the professionalism, and the amount they paid in cash for all the pieces. Very honestly and helpful.

Highly recommend this place, Davis is very smart and helpful. Informative and fair pricing, and they have beautiful pieces if interested in buying.

Excellent service! These guys are smart and honest in their business. Will definitely return in the future.

Stopped in with a bunch of watch batteries and a few watch band replacements. All repairs were done on premiss. Great place for a fast fix!

If your in need of a honest place to sell jewelry and watches this is by the best place. Completely honest about the gold and diamond prices.

Very polite, and felt they were very honest as well.

I stopped in at NYCity Buyers for an appraisal on some old jewelry. I was very impressed with the professionalism, and the amount they paid in cash for all the pieces.

Excellent service and cash when you need it! good peoples!!!

Services, Prices and Quality are Excellent