Had a great day with Quinn from start to finish. We caught over 20 fish and we able to keep the best. He prepared the fish for us to take home and provided good advice on other fishing spots. A wonderful family experience and would recommend Jersey Key Fishing Charters for a family day or for deep sea fishing trips.

We had a blast on the fishing charter! Thank you for a great day. Very informative, friendly, and awesome trip. Caught lots of fish. We will be back, thank you for the great experience

Went out with Captian Mike and Dylan. It was an amazing experience. They both were very patient and good with my children. We even caught a giant Sailfish!

We had an amazing fishing day with Mike and Dillon. It was a really windy day and they offered to take us out on the Atlantic to see if we wanted to continue the day. It was too choppy so they offered to take us on the bay and it was awesome! Finished the 4 hour fishing trip with 30 fish.

What a fantastic day of fishing! My 9 y.o. had the time of his life. We caught a ton of big fish. Captain Mike and First Mate Dylan were stars. Thank you gents.

Great day out with Mike and Dylan. They did everything they could to put us on some mahi and we caught some great ones and had fun.

Enjoyed a great day of fishing on this charter.Quinn was awesome!Caught our limit on snapper...hit the wrecks and landed a huge mutton snapper.Equipment and crew were outstanding!Thank You

Captain Mike was a great guide for fishing and put us on one of our biggest Mahdi’s yet! Family friendly and is willing to show you how to fish and what to do! Even when the water was rough he made the ride very safe and comfortable!

We decided we wanted to deep sea fish the last day we were in town. Thankfully they had a no show and was able to take us out for a half day. Connor and Dylan were great! They answered all our questions and were very helpful rebaiting our hooks and taking the fish off when caught. They were both very knowledgeable about the area as well. We caught our limit on Yellow Tail Snapper at one spot and then they took us out to a wreck. The waves were pretty big out there, so we didnt get to stay very long. However, I caught my first big fish, an African Pompano, in 160ft of water. it was amazing!! We went to one more spot, but the fish werent biting and it was time to get back. Although it was just one big fish caugh, the experience was really great! We will definitely be looking them up the next trip to take us out again.

Since the weather didnt cooperate for us & it was too windy to go offshore, Mike gave us a choice to go Bay fishing. Bay fishing is a lot of fun catching smaller fish which we did catch quite a few mangrove snapper which were delicious to eat! However, if you are looking for a big bite, you probably should just wait & book a different trip. Mike had handed the trip over to another captain, Quinn & his mate Dillon which was very nice & helpful baiting our line & removing all the fish. Very Nice Big 28 Clean Boat. Which you should make sure when booking your trip what boat you are booking since the bigger boat is more. When we booked, we were told $625 for 4 hours, But yet charged $730 since it was the bigger boat.

Captain Mike was fantastic. We booked a half day with him and despite the awful winds he put us on fish. I took home more than enough to eat and had a great time. He is a very knowledgeable guide and I highly recommend booking a trip with him.

Wow.What a great day to be had, fishing and trolling the waters with Capt Mike.We had a phenomenal day. Mike is a master at customer service and giving people the experience they want. He has fished and boated these waters most of his adult life and knows exactly where to go and how to make the trip enjoyable.

These guys will make sure you catch fish! Capt. Conner was great and we had an absolute great time. Online booking was easy and communication from Capt. Mike was great as well. I strongly recommend Jersey Key charters!

Great trip! Had a blast catching fish with this charter. Would highly recommend. Captain Quinn was great and we came back with lots of fish!!

Captain Mike and crew were AWESOME! We were on fish all afternoon and even finished the day by hooking a Spinner Shark. Mike was awesome, super nice and I HIGHLY recommend Jersey Key Charters! We will be back.

Top notch outfit and crew. Great personalities a pleasure to fish with. Will definitely book again.

Even though we werent able to go out because of high winds, Mike kept us informed throughout us waiting days for the weather to clear up. He was honest about our safety while on his boat and worried about our fishing experience to be enjoyable. We received a full refund. We cant wait for our next trip down to book again with Mike and Jersey Key Charters!

I will definitely go back to this guy we couldnt go out because of the high winds and he didnt just take my money and try for it he was honest

Had a great am trip out with Mike and Dylan. Had a nice catch of yellowtail snapper. Highly recommend Jersey Key Charters.

Captain Mike and Dillion were great! We had a horrible experience with another charter boat and Captain Mike really helped us out. Theyre both very professional and made sure we had a great experience. We will definitely be booking with them again next time were in Marathon.

I am a avid fisherman myself, i own my own boat and have been on multiple charters in the keys and Jersey Key Charters is by far the best one Ive been on. Even booked twice in one week! Captain Mike is great, took us right to fish and had them in the boat in no time at all, over 30 snappers and multiple Mahi before noon. 10/10 hands down . This is the best bang for your buck

Captain Mike and Dillion provided a wonderful fishing experience. They were attentive to our needs and were so knowledgeable of the area. We caught our limit easily as they knew where to take us to the hot spots. Highly recommend Jersey Key Charters!

Mike took 3 of my kids, my brother and I out yesterday. He took us out to a great spot with lots of action, mostly caught yellow tail. He is fun to be around and great with kids. Mike is very knowledgeable and will get you on whatever is biting. I highly recommend Jersey Keys and I will for sure be a repeat customer!!

Jersey Mike and Dillon put us on the fish! I am an inexperienced fisher and had never been on a charter before. I chose a half day on the reef and it was a blast. Next year I will definitely go for the full day offshore. They are very professional! Thanks again!!!

I can’t recommend Jersey Key Charters highly enough. Captain Mike offers a professional experience with a fun, laid back atmosphere. His fishing expertise quickly becomes evident after just a short time on the water. He is easily approachable and does not mind answering questions or sharing his knowledge. He always goes above and beyond to locate fish and is genuinely happy when someone aboard lands one. If you’re looking for a memorable charter, you can’t go wrong with the Jersey Key.

This was my wife and I, first time saltwater fishing and they put us on them and were really nice definitely recommending them to my friends!

Highly recommend this charter. Captain Mike has the experience to put you on the fish. A great boat and top of the line gear to help you bring in whatever species your targeting. Awesome experience. Cant wait to use him again.

Mike is a great captain. He’s very passionate about his craft and takes great care of the clients on his boat. He’s extremely fishy and gets excited every time there is a fish on. He’s very patient with beginners and knows how to get numbers and big fish in the boat. If you want a good captain and a great experience in the keys fishing... Captain Mike is your man.

I’ve been aboard the Jersey Key numerous time and from day one I knew this was the boat for me. Captain Mike makes it his mission to find fish and leave you with a wonderful experience and a lasting memory. Looking forward to the next trip. I highly recommend

Mike and Dillion is af 1st class charter. Put us on fish and kept us in the action. Extremely polite and patient with our less experienced anglers.

Highly recommend captain mike and his mate! We booked a last minute trip with him the night before and he made it happen for us! From starting with snappers to grouper and reeling in a 4 foot bull shark! We will be back! Thanks Mike!

I have fished with Captain Mike Sisto in the past, and based on the way he handles himself and his boat, I see myself fishing with him in the future as well! Great Captain great boat and great operation. Would highly recommend to anyone looking for a fun day out on the water with a Captain who definitely knows how to find fish!

Mike is the best Captain you can ask for went with him 2 times him and his first mate John are a great team and great fisherman they put me on fish that I never would have thought I would ever see anywhere but on TV. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND you book a trip with Jersey Key Sportfishing he is Awesome cant wait to come back.

Capt Mike Sisto is top notch, no question about it. He greets you like family the minute you step foot on his boat. Every little detail is taken care of before you even have to ask. Fishing is his passion and believe me it shows. I have fished with him in NJ and Marathon and he gives it 110% no matter what. Looking forward to my next trip with him.

Ive fished a lot of places and a lot of charters. Capt Mike is no contest, the best charter I have ever gone on. He knows how to get on the fish. I did a lot of research before picking my trip, so let me save you the trouble. Dont even bother looking anywhere else. Book now, and then again later.

Great trip. Captian Mike put us right on the fish. Extremely knowledgeable, and experienced. Couldn’t of asked for a better time.

I look forward to going out with Captain Mike every year. He always finds us fish. I caught my first sailfish with him and he made me a personal video as i was reeling it in so I can remember it forever. Its not just the fish either, Mike is a great guy and you will always have a great time on the Jersey Key. Ive used him for years and will never charter another Captain. He is my captain for life. THANKS CAPTAIN MIKE!!!! SEE YOU NEXT YEAR!

Mike flat out loves to fish and doesn’t care if he has to stay out longer or go further to put together a catch. Wish he was still running out of NJ

Captain Mike is well known in New Jersey for Stripers and Tautog (Tog) fishing. We secludedly chartered JK charter all season long up here in NJ. Mike goes out of his way to put his clients on fish and always offers tips and tricks to get that right bite. He knows the water well and always put the time in to research. I can’t wait to charter with him when in Florida!