Fantastic folks here. Im in from out of town and had concerns about my brakes. Garys team went for a ride with me to hear the noises and were able to troubleshoot the issue quickly. I highly recommend giving Garys a try.

Garys Auto Service is great. I feel cared for and valued by him. I also trust him. He is a stand up guy and so is his mechanic.

Excellent service! Good honest mechanics. Grateful for all there good works.

I do most of my own work but Im moving out of state so there were a few things I wanted done on my 2001 pickup. I have used Garys before so had him do a tune-up, new spark plugs and wires, repair the cabin air system and install a new fuel filter . He did it all for a very reasonable price. He took a great interest to make sure I wouldnt have any problems on my journey even though he couldnt expect any more business from me. He has my highest recommendation for knowledge, honesty and integrity.

Always great service and honest. we moved here about five years ago. We have taken are cars and truck to Garys to be worked on.

Great service, really good people, fair price, and fixed the car the 1st time around. VERY HAPPY WITH GARYS AUTO !!!

Great Reviews were correct. Wonderful experience.Diagnosed & repaired same day. Even a loaner car!!WOW

Kindest, most caring service. Recommend 10/10

Gary and his team are the top notch mechanics in Port Townsend! Got my vehicle in here early in the morning and for a Tune-Up/Check-Up as Im off for the road to California this month and cant be having any trouble while Im away. An afternoon later Im set and feeling less stressed. Even picked myself up a carton of fresh eggs for $4 on my way out the door!

A lot of great reviews.It takes only one time to get a crummy one. I was early for an appointment. The fellow at the desk said the other guy would be there shortly. There were no other customers. 10 minutes after my appointment time, I checked in again. The other guy had a dead battery, but was on his way. I waited a while, then just left.I called though, hoping to speak with Gary, but got the fellow at the desk. He asked if I wanted to reschedule. I said I didnt trust that Id be seen.He explained again the other guy had a dead battery, only this time it came out he was running an hour late. I might have sat in my car another 45 minutes (that is if the guy got there in an hour) waiting for an auto repair tecchnician or specialist who was running behind because he had a dead battery.I dont know.

Gary has always performed phenomenal service at a fair price!I normally never write a review for anything, but Gary has time and time again proved professional auto service.I would highly recommend putting your vehicle in his crews hands.Its worth the drive!

Great service, 5 stars really earned

Ive had cars (many) to shops throughout the Puget Sound region for around 50 years. Garys is the best shop Ive ever experienced. When our Ford Expedition had a Check Engine Soon event, and started missing badly, I took it in to a PT shop in town and was told they could look at it in two and a half weeks. We were trailer camping at Fort Warden and had only two days left on our campsite available. Called Gary around noon, he diagnosed it at 1:00 pm and had it ready to go by 5 that same day! And yes, he was reasonable and someone I instantly knew I could trust.

This place does a booming business, which speaks volumes in a small town. The cost came in lower than the estimate. Great guys with a sense of humor. We will return for car service.

Very good shop. The owner is a very kind, friendly and knowledgeable man, and his mechanics are as well. They are trustworthy and well worth taking your vehicle to them. Theyll treat you right.

Always amazing and honest service

Great service and prices.

5 fuel pumps FROM GARYS AUTO and still not running. took it to the number one guy at auto Aaron taylor.🙄 HE IS THE BEST

Gary and his mechanics are extremely honest and price very fairly. Ive called and brought my car in that same day a few times and he told me exactly what was wrong and didnt over charge me. My boyfriend and I both brought our cars in when we were driving across the country to make sure everything was okay and he assured us that everything was fine and didnt rip us off. Very friendly and reliable, I would trust Gary any time fixing my car.

Gary’s auto service came highly recommended. We were from out of town and were stranded. They got is back on the road and at a fair price.

Great Christian ran operation. Gary oversees bikers that have had serious accidents sometimes hes first on the scene to minister to them in case they dont make it. We had him work on our truck. Hes a guy you immediately realize is a trustworthy man and he and his wife are great people. I hardly ever complement business people in this manner but he deserves it. He has great analysis skills and explained to me why he did what he was doing and showed me how he was eliminating possible guesses of what was wrong with our truck so he could narrow it down more quickly. Turned out to be a fuel pump. He did a great job and the pump was inside the fuel tank. No problem he fixed it. Id recommend this man. Prices are very reasonable.

We just had our 2009 Accord in for the dreaded flashing malfunction light.Gary could fit us in the day of our call. He and his technician Aaron quickly surmised the problem and fixed it the same day. These two are wonderful. Gary is honest, friendly and knowledgeable.Word of warning - driving up to his shop can throw you and the condition of the shop makes you question your choice. Dont hesitate. This is one of the best car repair experiences I have had in over 30 years. We are sold and will be bringing all of our automotive repairs to Gary.Thanks a million Gary and Aaron!

Gary again repaired my BMW in good time at a fair price. Such a personable and honest man. And great technicians. The only place to take your import.

Great place 👍👌

These guys are really good. I thought I had a pretty serious issue with my 1990 Toyota motorhome, and the thing is tough to work on. It was hard to find a shop that could fit me in in a timely manner, but Gary did. Even though he was very busy, he understood that I was pressed for time and managed to get me in within a couple of days. I was expecting to hear I would have to schedule some major repairs, and I was very pleasantly surprised when Gary called saying the thing was fixed a couple of hours later. The bill was reasonable (he could have charged a lot more and performed unnecessary work, but is obviously very honest) and I couldnt be happier.

Knowledgeable mechanics and Gary, the owner, is a really nice guy. Unfortunately, they were unable to discover what was wrong and by car. After having it a year, I finally found a mechanic that discovered what was causing the draw on my battery.

I had a problem where I needed a repair immediately, without an appointment. Gary stepped up to the situation, and took care of me straight away! I got the repair I needed, I was treated well, and I was given a fair price! I would highly recommend Gary for someone who will do right by you regarding your auto repair needs.

Imagine, car repair people you can 100% trust.... Gary and his talented mechanics are those people. Totally worth the drive down a country road to get to them. They are Awesome and Affordable!!

We just moved to the area and this morning our minivan had a plastic part underneath the engine that was dragging on the ground. I called Garys Auto Services, and was shocked that he told me to just come right over now. The shop is a little off the beaten path, but well worth the drive. Gary and his mechanic were just awesome!!! Within 10 minutes of me getting there, they had the car lifted up, fixed and ready to go. This was very appreciated especially since I had two little ones in tow with me. They were kind, price was right, and we are excited to have found our new mechanic!

Gary is a great mechanic. Very friendly, a good listener and he has the reasonable prices compared to other mechanics Ive received quotes from. I came in to get a second opinion on a job that I had received a $1300 quote from another questionable mechanic, well, Gary looked over my truck and told me that I didnt need the work that was recommended to me by the other mechanic and most importantly, he caught another dangerous issue that had been overlooked by that other mechanic. Plus, it would only cost $170. Its better than $1300 bucks. Well, I look at this way, he saved my life and also saved me about $1100. I travel 2 hours to see Gary, because I dont trust anyone else, especially for being a woman. He definitely has a lifetime customer in me!! Thanx Gary :)

These guys are great. I came to them asking for advice regarding a vehicle I was considering buying and they freely offered their advice that the vehicle was overpriced to the extent that it was not worth me paying them to make a pre-purchase inspection. It can be difficult finding honest mechanics, but they treated me with nothing but respect and integrity. Would recommend.

The folks at Garys Auto Service are so friendly and honest! Gary treated me with respect and integrity, SO important when looking for a mechanic! My car was done on time and on budget.Thanks,Gary!

Had an emergency, called with no notice to five different auto places. Garys listened to my issue and actually took time out of his day to help. Great customer service and straight forward and helpful

Were down from Canada and stranded with a transmission that had to be replaced, Gary found one and repair was completed and in working order. Great customer service by Gary and the rest of the team.

A very honest place to have your car worked on.

Very polite owner gets the job done right

Ive been dreading the trouble and expense of having my clutch replaced. This Mechanic is straightforward and very fair and kind; even loaned a car for our use while he worked. He got the job done sooner and for less than Id anticipated and I couldnt be happier w the results. Hes one of the good ones! Thanks Gary.

Very fair, great attitude, great customer service. Number one garage to use in East Jefferson County, if not the Peninsula!

Great work, fair prices.

Straight forward, honest, affordable auto repair. We would go to Gary again in a heartbeat.

Garys shop is honest and does great work.

Great honest service

Great guy, Great Mechanic!!!

So far, so good!! Always very pleasant and honest about automotive needs.