Seafood Fra Diavolo was awesome. So glad I ventured off the interstate as I passed through. 5 star food for a 2 star price. You won’t be disappointed.

Absolutely delightful waitress, awesome food. Love your restaurant.

Food was amazing! Party of 12 and things went smoothly, great waiter. Everyone loved their entrees and apps. Will def go back. Sauce was delicious, better than most. Salads were fresh and italian dressing was sooo good. Took sauce home to enjoy

The food is absolutely amazing. Great service and will go back!!!!

Great place to go for great food. The dinner theater is fantastic, and such a great time. This family owned business makes you feel like your part of the family!

Excellent food, thanks for accommodating our family after the funeral they did an outstanding job

I ordered a chicken salad, they used frozen chicken strips not sure if they were Tyson, but I know it was not a piece of grilled chicken. I informed the waiter that I would not eat it, they did take it off the bill, but I would expect that from a fast food restaurant.

The host/owner always has good vibes, ready to seat us. The food is always good here. The scallops are very good here. Always happy with our experience when we come here.

Food is delicious, fast service cant ask for anything better

Love this place. Great atmosphere. Staff is excellent

Pasta con Vodka delicious! Always a welcoming greeting by the owner.

First timers. Fish fry was so big! Shrimp scampi over pasta was delicious. Food was HOT! staff was great. Watched them all frying around. Going back of scallops next time.

Very surprised...went there for Mothers day for the first time and we were able to reserve a table for 8 the day before...the food was excellent and service was great!

Food portion for the fish fry was almost comical as far as the sides go. The sides were put in condiment containers and filled halfway?

First time there and everything was incredible. Service was prompt and pleasant, the food was tasty and came in large portions. Will definitely be back to this place, we are so glad we discovered it!

Food was good but the server was horrible. Will not be going back

Phenomenal experience. I had the linguine alfredo. It was fresh and delicious. Service was exceptional

The food was amazing and the portions were right for the price. We also enjoyed the drinks

Jay and his brother, Bobs, attention to detail is extraordinary! Their meals are beautifully prepared and NEVER disappoint🤙‼️

Large portions,reasonably priced.Food was very good,taste was excellent

The food was excellent. The gnocchi was the best Ive ever had. Texture was perfect and the sauce was delicious. Service was great as well.

Great food, terrific staff and a nice atmosphere.

Food and service were excellent. The facility could be cleaner, especially the bathroom.

Great, friendly service and delicious Italian food! Everything was on point for us. I recommend the cheesy garlic bread.

Great food great service. Theyve got it down.

Excellent manicotti and spaghetti parm, everything was very fresh and filling my husband and I enjoyed this place very much! French onion soup and stuffed banana peppers were absolutely amazing also sorry forgot to take pictures of them! If you live around the area it is a must go to!

Great service! Food was very good and portions huge..Husband says the tripe was as good as Moms! Pasta dish delicious too!

Awesome place great people and great environment very friendly.

Prompt service and friendly server

Awesome food awesome drinks awesome service

Amazing food - great atmosphere. Awesome people

Great food, music and atmosphere. I always love coming here. Ive never been disappointed and the service has always been so friendly. I recommend to anyone and everyone to come and try it out!

Soooooo good.

Owners are always engagedFish fry with garden salad and fresh bread best in wny

Wonderful dinner & great staff

Exceptional Italian food, well run family restaurant. Would recommend to anyone who enjoys eating delicious food!

My girlfriend and I had a perfect night out thanks to the Desiderio family and their staff. We were treated like we were at a family dinner. The mood, the ambiance, the greeter (Rob), our server, everything was spot on and oh yeah, the food-fantastic! Its no coincidence that they have been serving the Buffalo community for decades with absolute professionalism and attention to detail like no other. Th

Ordered last night and it was amazing. Ordered Chicken Milanese and who ever cooked it, it was the best I ever had. Served with greens and a garlic and oil pasta. My husband ordered pasta Tommy. We always have to order a artichoke, which was delicious. Cant wait for them to open again.

Excellent food, great service, always very injoyable.

Best Italian food I’ve even eaten ....Delicious!!!!

I had the spaghetti and meatball parmigiana...the meatballs had a great flavor and I liked the sauce too...everyone else had different pizzas and other pasta dishes and everyone was happy with their food...our server Krystina was really nice and fast...not a single complaint!

Owners are like visiting your favorite uncles. EVERY item is delicious. Staff is wonderful. Customers behave like old neighborhood friends. Best sauces in Buffalo

American food, yeah, so great. Food was so appetizing. Prices are appropriate for the quality. This place has great reviews for a reason.

The Broiled Haddock is Delicious & the Risotto was extraordinary, along with the Broccoli! A Very Pleasant Surprise!All the Meals Ive had have been Delicious!

Stuffed peppers oh my !!! Bob and Jay serve the BEST stuffed peppers around ( and have the plaque on the wall to prove they won). Their menu has everything and more. Last week we had spaghetti and meatballs - 5 Stars !!! The homemade sauce is AMAZING !!! Wings at the bar with a few “pops” are very good as well. If you order them hot .... your going to need an extra napkin to clear the sweat of your forehead... hot but flavorful !!!

Absolutely delicious! Sauce was amazing. Great atmosphere. Would highly recomnend.

Me and my wife have been going to Bobby Js for probably 4 years now. The food is always excellent it cant be beat. The waitresses do a fine job and are friendly. They also have a dinner theater that we have attended which is always a good evening of food and entertainment. Their prices arent cheap but then you get what you pay for. This isnt McDonalds.

My go to for Italian food

Fish fry on Friday was very good

It was very clean, reasonably priced, huge menu. All of our party was pleased with their meals. I had Chicken Pad Thai which was perfectly prepared. However it was double amount I was able to eat. Next time Ill have it plain without chicken so it wont go to waste.

Excellent food and service!

Last minute decision to order in for Mother’s Day. Most places were only taking pre-orders. However, the staff at Bobby J’s were so nice and happy to take an order. It was ready right when they said it would be. The food was incredible! The portions were a good size and the focaccia bread that came with the meals was still warm when we got it home to eat. I will definitely be ordering from here again.

Food is always great! Sat at the bar and had fantastic service. Great place!!!

We had a unannounced party of 10 and they accommodated us with no problem. The sauce was like my old Italian grandmother used to make. The meatballs were huge. The sandwiches were great. My sister had shrimp scampi which she loved. The service was fantastic, we had 5 kids age 2 to 8 to 5 adults and they were great with our party.

Bobby Js, (Militellos) Restaurant and Dinner Theatre was an Excellent Package Deal!!! The atmosphere was inviting, and service was pleasant and friendly. The food (I had the rib-eye steak) was absolutely delicious, cooked to perfection, with generous portions! The highlight of the evening was the play that is currently playing, A Time to Kill. The actors are all excellent in their individual roles, and the collective cast superbly perform, and seamlessly interact with the audience, pulling them in as participants in the climatic ending. This play runs until the end of June, and is a must see. You dont want to miss it!

This place is a local favorite. The food is delicious, plenty to choose from. The attached bar is always hopping and everyone you meet is friendly and accommodating. They also have a dinner theater, where you can eat dinner and watch a show which is awesome. I visit here often.

Good food great play columbo

Great food at fair pricing. House Italian dressing is perfection, fresh hot bread, the kind with a perfectly crisp crust. Owners frequently mingle among customers making sure you are happy with your dinner. You wont be disappointed in this fine restaurant. Oh what a dish is my favorite special as are the fried smelts.

The food and service was excellent. One of the owners greeted and welcomed us, and also checked on us during our meal letting us know how happy he was we came in. Our server was attentive and friendly. We had the Buffalos Best stuffed hot pepper appetizer, which was delicious, but the highlight for me was the shrimp, scallop, calamari pasta dish. Large, plentiful, tender seafood with a tomato sauce over linguini...I will definitely order that again! My husband had gnocchi which is his go to Italian choice. We found a new favorite restaurant and I may come back with my sister for the dinner theater.

I love coming here to see my favorite band, Back To The Bars. The menu is great! We had a Fish Fry, Stuffed Mushrooms, and Stuffed Hot Peppers that were out of this world! Such a fantastic place, all the way around!

My wife and I were looking to try something new. She was in the mood for Italian cuisine and I was craving a burger. Neither one of us had ever been to Bobby Js before our recent Sunday night visit. I drive by the place all the time, so its about time we gave them a try. We got there kinda late, so it wasnt busy. Staff was very friendly. They have a wonderful list of beers and wines, there is something for everyone. The food was delicious. My wife got an alfredo dish, and I got the burger Id been craving. All that was pretty good, but the most memorable part was that we discovered they serve stuffed artichokes. The way her great grandma used to make! It was heavenly. We will definitely be back again.

Pretty good

Great food and atmosphere.

Fun atmosphere. Go to dance to an engaging, boomer era band. They get the patrons singing along. Drinks are noticeably tasty. Theyve kept up with modern food styles. Attentive owner.

I was introduced to BOBBY Js about a year ago. Quite simply if you truly have a discerning palate & demand unique creative & layered culinary creations then you can find 99.9% consistent delight at Bobby Js. The owners are so gracious & talented hosts. The staff are polite and so pleasant. Their sauce compares to the best of true homemade & their specials transport one to the roots of gourmet grandmas sunday dinners.

Food was amazing and prices are great

Large variety of Italian food made with fresh ingredients. Sauce, meatballs, & seafood gumbo soup were delicious. Ravioli had pasta that was cooked perfectly & scrumptious. The large dining room was tastefully decorated. There was a large table of about 20 patrons seated comfortably. Server was kind & attentive. Prices are reasonable & food arrived in a timely manner. We will be back here!

Fantastic and well priced Italian food. This was my first time eating here with my family. Everyone loved there food including my kids. Had the mushroom ravioli and the gnocchi. Both were fantastic. Finished off with a limoncello layer cake . All was excellent.

Delightful! Primarily at the bar for a retirement party, never had a long wait for service. The barmaid was extremely attentive, friendly and the drinks were nice and cold! Perfect!Friends and I will definitely return.

A good menu with many choices. Good food with friendly service. A great place for a big gathering

Best Italian food in the city awesome staff and atmosphere. Excellent experience.

Today was my second visit and Danielle (server) remembered my first visit several weeks ago. As with my first visit the food was very good. They’re sauces are very tasty and the portions are generous. So far I’ve tried the lasagna and the Fettuccine Alfredo with Cajun chicken added. The chicken wasn’t very Cajun but was still nice. I will probably skip it the next time. The Lasagna was delicious all the way around. Yum! We’ll have to see what my next visit brings because I will go back! Also, they have a nice wine selection!

My husband and I come often....for a few reasons! Atmosphere is so cool and food is super amazing! My sisters birthday was today and chose to come here after our celebratory sky diving birthday jump and can say that our party of 6 was super happy and the food was spot on and to die for!!! Thanks for ending our amazing day with some great food memories! Your smelts are to die for!

The hot banana peppers were excellent! The spaghetti and meatballs were good. Everything is overpriced and the portions were small. If you want a little extra sauce, they charge extra. Have been to much better Italian restaurants.

We had a birthday party here for 15 people. Our group ordered a wide variety of food. In general, most felt their meals were excellent. A few were good, but not excellent. The Cajun chicken didnt have any kick. The waitress was attentive, but struggled to get the meals in the right places. I would definitely recommend a visit. The menu is large and offers something for everyone

The food and service was delicious and friendly

Excellent food and prices. Great service. Many unique entrees and specials

1st time at Bobby Js. Great atmosphere. Live music was fantastic. Ordered food ( Stuffed Peppers) while enjoying the music....highly recommend a trip to Bobby Js..

Nice suburban feel to the place. The food was great - nicely cooked ramen and parmesan chicken. The quantity was generous, the biggest drawback for the day was that the server was not polite and despite me telling her that I just wanted one dish (which I had asked her to suggest - the most popular one on the menu) she brought over 2 dishes. They did not charge me for the other dish which was returned but the server seemed unhappy with the mistake despite it being her fault.

This is a wonderful place for a couple to have excellent food and than remain seated and view a play. Bobby Js is expensive but worth it, you enjoy a great meal and the play offered. The quality of the acting varies but generally good to excellent. The food is excellent with a simple menu offering pasta, veal, or steak. Jay is an engineer in theatre. He will explain the process prior to the opening act with clarity and passion, ensuring that the audience has an understanding of what the actors are conveying. The most recent play is a comedy of the preparation of a drama. Kid left college and lives with mom. Moms boyfriend has conflict with child. The play is about the actors rehearsing to get to opening day. Hilarious competent acting. Since I worked in the MP industry it rang quite true to me. One thing, dont expect Bobby Duvall, or Meryl Strep. You will find local people doing remarkable work on a small stage with minimum props and staging taking you to the place desired by the author of the play.

Just had a great birthday dinner at Bobby Js . Food? Delicious! Service? Excellent! Cost/value ratio? Great! Couldnt ask for more!

Great food (manicotti w/meatballs was excellent). Great service. A number of private or semi private dining rooms available.

Food was very good and well priced for the portions. I had the tortellini alfredo which was very good. Danielle our waitress took very good care of us.

I had an absolutely terrible experience.I placed an order for pickup I was told it would be 45 minutes. I was then called back and told it would be an hour and 10 minutes If I still wanted the food Which I was totally okay with That. Then another call saying They werent going to do Pick up orders until after 8 and my order would be completely canceled. But I can call back later and reorder if I wanted to.I strongly recommend Not ordering from this establishment for takeout Unless you want to waste. 20 minutes on food, you cant even receive.

A great find. I want to go back soon. I wish someone had told me about them earlier, thanks Google. They have great food and cold beer. I had the Shrimp Scampi, and it was the best I ever had. The mushroom appetizers are excellent too

Food was amazing. Got the spaghetti parmesan, tortellini and meatballs. Great atmosphere and service. Food came out in a good amount of time. Overall a very good experience. Will definitely be back again.

A very nice menu 👌. We went for lunch and were told we could order anything. The red sauce on our spaghetti was certainly homemade. Outstanding food!

Oh, my my! If you are a artichoke lover this is a must try. It is a HUGE artichoke stuffed with cheesy deliciousness. The meat on the leaves was tender and it came right off. We also had the tripe, the sauce was the best I have ever had. It was sweet and complicated the tender tripe. I really didnt have high expectations for the tripe but I could not get enough. I will definitely go back there again.

Food is absolutely amazing, very flavorful and the staff was very nice. Great experience definitely would recommend for a date night or just to have some lunch or dinner.

Alfredo was really REALLY good! Also, the ravioli! Try the Viberti Barbera..... Danielle was exceptional, especially considering we had a five-year old with us......great evening.

Excellent meal, awesome show. If you love delicious food 😋 and compelling and humorous theater, you must experience it for yourself. I love love love the stuffed mushrooms and the chicken marsala. Cant wait to see the next show.

Went as group from church. Service was good, they served big portions of salad and 2 meats. Food was very good, huge portions of chicken and pork chops, mashed potatoes, which were a bit gummy and sweet and sour cabbage, corn, ice cream for dessert.Good place to book your parties.

The food is good.

The food was excellent the service was great in the hospitality was amazing. I would definitely go back there again

I had the chicken parm last night, and got very sick . that was our first time there . dont know if Ill go back . my wifes lasagna was very good .

Fabulous food and service. The dinner theater does not disappoint.

Definitely not impressed. The food was fine but GROSSLY overpriced. It shouldn’t cost me $16 for a chicken wrap, fries, and a soda at lunch. Maybe if service was good I could overlook it, but the waitress was snotty. She misunderstood my coworker’s order and he politely pointed out the mistake and instead of apologizing and/or offering to fix it, she talked to him like he was an idiot who didn’t know what he ordered. Will not be back!

Great food.... All home made! Awesome service....

Great food, even better service (thanks Danielle), reasonable prices, and did I mention great food.

Another great meal at BobbyJs. I have been here on numerous occasions and I am never disappointed. The service was great and food was amazing as always.