Great to work with. Got a good value and quick to respond

I helped my daughter by getting home and auto insurance quotes. Dustin was very helpful in providing those.

Dustin was such a help in getting my car insured in a flash. Very easy to work with and very professional

Joel Hyde is absolutely fantastic to work with. Can’t recommend him and his company enough!

If you want an insurance agent who will give you great customer service and a great value, contact Colligan. I emailed them and got a detailed quote the next day. They made switching providers super easy and now were saving money and getting better coverage. I never even needed to visit the office. Highly recommended.

Dustin made switching our insurance painless, quick and easy! We ended up paying less for more coverage and it was a seamless transition! Thank you👏

Bought a new house and Dustin was on top of it! He got in contact with my loan company and asked a few questions and now my house is covered. Super efficient, quick and clean! Could not be happier! Thank you Colligan & Company and THANK YOU Dustin Shirey!

We have been working with Dustin for several years now and are very happy. He is always quick to respond and has been helpful finding us the best coverage for us. We would highly recommend working with Dustin and Colligan and Company.

I was referred to Dustin by a mutual friend as I was shopping for a new provider after spending the past 17 years with the same agent. I dreaded the entire process as it typically becomes a drag and a lot of work for the consumer. That was not the case with Dustin, he made the process very streamline, little effort on my part, and saved me nearly $1000 annually. Highly recommend.

Dustin Shirey was excellent to work with. He was able to pull quotes together from multiple locations for my auto and home owners insurance. He saved me over $200 a year from my previous insurance, which was the lowest cost I was able to find on my own. The best part? I even have more coverage than I previously did! I also love the fact that I have an agent I can work with every single time instead of a generic call center! Thanks for all the hard work Dustin!

Dustin has been fantastic for us. He made switching insurance so easy and has always been super responsive when we have had questions. We will be with Colligan & Company for all of our insurance needs as long as possible.

Dustin from Colligan’s Insurance was quick and thorough when I contacted him about purchasing policies for both home and auto insurance. I won’t consider anyone else when doing further business. Additionally, the support staff at Colligans showed professionalism and friendliness with every contact.Good job Colligans!

Great experience as we were looking to switch insurance companies. Jeremy met with me a few times and was willing to review our current policy and provide a side by side comparison. He did a great job explaining everything and I never felt pressured into any kind of decision. I would highly recommend these guys!

Dustin is the best! He made switching super easy and provided lots of good options. We saved money and got way better coverage!

Colligan & Company - Insurance Agency offers superior service for all your insurance needs. They work to get you the best price and truly customize your plan to fit the needs of the entire family. I have been with this “local” company for several years and have always received the best customer service. They work hard to get you the best rate available to your family. Believe me when I say, from experience, you do not want to deal with national insurance agencies in times of need. You want to work with a local agency that actually has some sweat equity within the community. I have stopped in the office a few times just to ask some simple questions. Friendly staff, always accommodating. Would highly recommend for any insurance needs you may have!

Dustin was great to work with he was quick to respond to all my questions, able to save me money, and help me obtain the correct coverage for my multiple dwellings during buying our new home as well as the home we are selling. I would highly recommend anyone to give them a call for a great insurance experience!

Colligan & Co. is an amazing company to work with. Through the course of 10+ years of being with them, my wife and I have had a few car wrecks and they are the most attentive and supportive individuals you can imagine. I’ve also used them to insure our business in several capacities and the customer service is incredible. Anytime I need something or have a simple question, they are a quick phone call away, as opposed to calling an 800 number and waiting on hold to talk to someone who just doesn’t care because there is no relationship. I’d recommend Joel and Jeremy and the rest of the team to anyone!

These guys are Tops. Good people, full of integrity, big heart for customer service and investing in the community. No need to go anywhere else. These guys care deeply about making sure insurance needs are met in a strategic way. As a business owner, they are my go to insurance team.

Jeremy and his team at Colligan & Company were extremely helpful to us in buying home owners insurance for our new home purchase. They were prompt in getting us a competitive quote and educating us through the process. Would highly recommend them to anyone looking for homeowners insurance.

I cannot say enough about Jeremy and his Staff, they are always so welcoming and NEVER make you feel like an interruption. Not only did Jeremy take the time to go through every part of my policies to make sure I understood exactly what I was doing, but he helped my budget as well. I have more/better coverage than before and paying a little less, we could all use that, right? If you are looking for a new company or just starting out, I would HIGHLY recommend Colligan & Company. They are very involved in the Community as well, which is a winner in my book, love to see local companies support each other.

Joel at Colligan & Company has been my agent for almost 12 years. He remembers me, is friendly, returns my calls and answers my questions promptly. He is almost always available when I need something, and even if he’s not, the other people in the office are willing to try to help. I have made four claims (one house and three car) during this time period and they have all been taken care of quickly and covered things I did not expect. I really do love working with Joel and Colligan as a whole.

Great people. Great care. Very personal. Colligan & Co. really looked after my family and helped us find the best insurance possible. I would highly recommend them.

I started shopping for a new insurance agent when my daughter started driving and my rates went through the roof and found Dustin Shirey. He was very helpful and not pushy. I had been with my previous agent for 20 years so I was nervous about making the switch. It took me a few weeks to decide and at no point did I feel pressured. I would definitely recommend Dustin and his team.

Very helpful, very professional. Any questions we had we solved right away and every problem we had got fix almost immediately I would recommend them to all my friends

Ive was referred to dustin Shirey by a good friend and hes been there for me day, night,weekends and even when hes on vacation he still has me covered!

Nothing but good experiences working with these folks. They give great advice and are just really good people. My one claim went very smoothly. You cannot go wrong here. Thanks guys!

This is a very personal and professional company. I am confident that my insurance needs are being met at a fair price but even more important to me is the excellent costumer service. I strongly recommend this insurance agency.

Jeremy is the best. Great prices and always has our back. He found us a great policy for our home and cars. We will be using him for all of our insurance needs.

Character & Competence are the driving forces in most decisions made by consumers. You will find that Colligan & Co display both very well. We feel like part of the family when working with this great company. Not just another number with them.

Colligan & Company is the best insurance company we have had the pleasure of doing business with. The company’s agents are very personable, thorough and follow up quickly when contacted with a question or need! We would highly recommend this company to anyone needing a quote.

My best experience with insurance and the agents. Joel has been responsive to every question and concern weve ever had and advocated for us to get the insurance that best met our needs at a price that worked for our budget. I highly recommend Joel Hyde and Colligan & Company.

Love working with Jeremy, Joel, and Karen. So much knowledge so professional and a class act for sure! Colligan & Company has it all for your insurance needs. Highly recommend!!

I switched to Colligan & Company a couple years ago because I trust the owners will have my and my familys best interest in mind and make any potential claim as easy of a process as it can be. If youre thinking of switching insurance companies, I highly recommend Colligan & Co.

Weve really enjoyed working with everyone at Cooligan & Co. They are very friendly and highly professional. They also represent multiple carriers which allowed me to have some different options to pick from. Id strongly recommend giving them a call.

My experience with Colligan & Company was fantastic. When you typically think of insurance shopping you usually equate it to the fun had during your most recent trip to the dentist. This was far from what I experienced with Colligan. Jeremy offered prompt quotes, detailed explanations, and quick feedback all while saving me money. I really appreciate Jeremy and his teams hardwork and lookforward to continued service from Colligan.

We feel like Colligan treats us like family. They are honest and fair, and they always act as our advocate. It is a nice change from what you may be used to in dealing with insurance companies

Dustin has been fantastic to work with, taking care of all my insurance needs! Especially his lightning quick responses. Great company to work with

We have been using Colligan & Company for almost 10 years and they are great! Fast replies. Friendly service. Knowledgeable agents.

We have been with Colligan and Company for almost 12 years. Through 2 homes and several cars, they have provided top notch service and always responds in a timely fashion. We would definitely recommend Joel Hyde and Colligan and Company to anyone we know!

I have found the service and advice we receive from Colligan to be top notch. We have been pleased with our decision to move our home, auto and umbrella policies to them and would recommend them to others.

I found Colligan through a Facebook suggestion. I have primarily worked with Dustin S. He is quick to respond, no matter what time of day. I have switched all my policies over and am pleased with my coverages & pricing. As a bonus, I also referred my sister and received free Mikes car wash vouchers and a star bucks gift card. I wouls highly recommend this company for fair pricing, great customer service, and superior professionalism.

Dustin has always provided excellent professional service. Almost like you’re part of the family. Great options and lowest rates around!!

Great customer service. Recently switched ALL my home,business and auto over to Colligan, and Dustin saved me over $2000.00 total. Highly recommend Colligan and Company.

Knowledgeable and conscientious owners and staff. What a wonderful team to work with.

We have used Joel Hyde at Colligan & Company Insurance Agency for many years now, and have always received the highest quality customer service. We would highly recommend you call them for all your insurance needs.

Our family have been clients for many years. The staff is always ready and able to help with changes to our policies and even with claims. Everything is personal and we are never referred to an 800 number. Thanks - Fran

Great people, great service, and I trust them 100%.Thank you Colligan and Co for making an insurance company worth dealing with.

Dustin and team are amazing. Competitive rates and amazing customer service. Highly recommend.

Dustin worked very hard to get me the help I needed after allstate screwed me over on my rates... Thanks buddy

Colligan & Co has handled my personal and business insurances for years. Integrity and excellent customer focus are the hallmarks of this agency. If you’re looking to land at a new agency for the rest of your life, you found it.

No issue, always provided me with great service.Respond with answers for all my questions in timely manner.

I’ve been with Colligan for about three years and have been pleased with their personalization and professionalism. The team is friendly, knowledgeable, and quick to communicate with their clients!

Great rates and coverage!! Excellent customer service with quick response time.

Good 2nd to none company, with speedy response time, excellent service to their customers!

We have experienced nothing but prompt service and professionalism from Jeremy and the staff at Colligan & Company. We are very glad we switched and highly recommend this company.

Everyone at Colligan is super helpful! Greatly appreciate all their hard work

Colligan and Co are so friendly and supportive, especially when something happens and you need their help!

To me, Colligan represents the best of the insurance world--honest people who care about other people and provide a valuable service.

I get tired of insurance people calling you constantly. They promised they wouldn’t. They are the best insurance company period!

I was trying to start a new business and couldnt find insurance until I got ahold of colligan and it was nice being able to walk in and talk to Dustin in person and they got me everything I need

Have always had great service from the Colligan team from far away.

It’s really nice having an agent that is reliable and acts quick when needed. Dusty Shirey goes out of his way to be available and prompt!

We recently switched to using Colligan & Co. as our insurance agent. Jeremy is easy to work with and showed genuine interest in making sure our needs were met

The service with Colligan is top notch. I would recommend them to anyone who needs insurance

Responsive, knowlegable, servant-minded group. Highly recommend.

Great company, great people! Give them a call!

Very helpful and knowledgeable about all the different insurances out there

These guys do a great job at everything they do.

They make my insurance awesome

Smart, Problem Solvers, Great Listeners, Prompt Service!

Great service, great people. Couldn’t ask for a better agency

My husband and I have been with Joel and Colligan for years, we would never switch to anywhere else!

Excellent Service!

Excellent customer service!

Great personal service!

Good guys

Great Company - excellent service