During the past few days, it was my good pleasure to work with Agent Karen McKee-Amato to acquire insurance on my property. I found her to be personable, responsive and ultra efficient. She explained what needed to be done and kept me informed in every step in the process. When I was in a panic state for not having the insurance that I needed she was very calming in relieving my anxiety and left me with the feeling that everything was going to be alright. With this I highly recommend her and her company.

Karen McKee-Amato was an exceptional insurance agent who helped us with our home and auto insurance policies. She was not only pleasant to speak with and answer all of our questions, she helped lower our rates and who couldnt be happy with that? Thank you Karen!

Karen was especially helpful when I had a claim. I hope to have her overseeing my insurance needs far into the future.

Great insurance company. Endless options of insurance company choose from. When you need one quote you get back 4-6 options with all different companies.

We have been commercial clients of this agency for 13 or so years. Before that we were with some of the largest insurance brokers in the country. Bill Willard and his team have been the best insurance people we have ever worked with. Debbie Barbra has been our account manager the entire time and has done an excellent job. She always provides prompt, accurate, and cheerful service. We have several locations and getting certificates out each year can be a bit crazy but Paula Boozer handles that promptly and professionally. Definitely 5 stars and the highest of recommendations to the entire agency.

I have been using Choice Insurance Group for several years now and have nothing but accolades for their service and rates. Kelly was very thorough in her proposals and now Josh has been maintaining our accounts since. Always quick on his response time with questions and is very accessible. I highly recommend using them!

Sara Peifer is my agent and has done a phenomenal job helping me. She quickly answers any questions I have and is very professional. I recently asked her to renew my policy because I am a landlord and she was able to find me a policy with a lower premium very quickly. She explained all the paperwork and made the process very simple. 10/10 would recommend.

Sara Pfeffer of Choice Insurance Agency is hands down the best agent I have dealt with in my 35 years of home owner experience. They offer a broad array of services and conduct thorough research to make sure your property is adequately protected and at the best rate. They are exceptionally prompt in handling business via email and phone.I highly recommend them to handle any of your property insurance needs.

Ive called several times of the last three months and yet to have received a call back and I have emailed several times and they also dont respond. Theyve also set me up with the wrong type of insurance so I will be taking my business to another insurance company. Wouldnt recommend.

We have been customers of Billy Willard and Debbie Barbra for years. They are always professional, thorough and a pleasure to work with! Billy is one of the most honest people you will ever meet!

I have been dealing with Debra Barbara and Bill Williard for over 20 years now at Choice Insurance. I would never leave them and would always recommend them to anyone! Our business relationship has turned into a great friendship. Prices and service is always TOP notch.

Brandi is awesome. Coming back to the United States was stressful enough but to have to search for a good Insurance agent just added to it. Luckily my daughter already had Brandi and couldnt say enough things about her. I am so happy I went with Brandi. She got me the best deals and saved me a bunch of money. Cant say enough about her.

I have been working Debbie Barbra and her team for years and have always received best in class service. They really make you feel like part of the family.

Choice Insurance Agency is professional, responsive, and goes the extra mile to ensure customers receive the best possible coverage at the most cost-effective price. Serving as the intermediary between the client and the carrier, they help make the entire insurance experience so much more agreeable.

I have been with Choice for years and they still provide me with the best service and the best rates. I highly recommend them to anyone looking for an insurance provider.

Nicole McGill was fast, prompt and efficient. Needed insurance to close on a cash real estate purchase and had a quote within 10 minutes and the rate was better than any other company I shopped. She did this at 5pm! Highly recommend.

Normally dealing with insurance can be a confusing hassle, but this was no where near the case. Good employees are very had to come by. So when I encountered a GREAT ONE (Nicole McGill) I was very relieved to be assisted by her. She made signing up for insurance extremely easy, efficient, and understandable just the way I like things.

Nicole McGill was easy to talk to! She gave me a very quick quote for both my home insurance and auto. The process of getting everything switched over was a breeze. Definitely recommend!

Recently, we had to switch from homeowners’ insurance to renters’ insurance. Nicole McGill was our customer service representative. She made the transition seamless! Moving is such a pain, but this was one step that was very simple for us! Thank you, Nicole, for lessening our stress levels!!~Mike Richardson

Extremely professional and courteous service. Would highly recommend their services.

Suzette in the Rocky Mount office has excellent customer service and I will definitely refer her location to others.

Nicole was awesome! Great customer service. It was super fast and pleasant speaking with her! She is highly trained to do her job! Thanks Choice!

I have called several insurance companies to compare prices and have to say that Choice Insurance has some of the best rates. Great customer service! I had plenty of questons and I have to say that Nicole McGill was very friendly and knowledgeable. She answered every question I had and never made me feel ignorant for asking. I will definitely be recommending Choice Insurance to my family and friends. Nicole is an asset to your company, she will be highly recommended as the agent to speak with.

C.A.R.R. Insurance Services is the best!! I was able to save money by switching from my prior insurance. I also received great Customer Service and helpful Information that I have not received from previous insurance company’s.Thank you for all that you have done !!!

Nicole McGill was very helpful and was able to save me a lot of money on my Home and Car insurance. She was fast, very professional and friendly. Many thanks to her!

We have a longstanding relationship with Debra Barbara and Bill Williard at Choice Insurance. I would recommend them wholeheartedly. They are responsive to our needs and are always a pleaseure to work with!

Nicole McGill is an awesome agent! She was very quick in tending to my needs and a very friendly person to talk to. I would recommend her to anyone and everyone. Thank you!

Nicole McGill wrote an auto policy for me and saved me a lot of money! She gave awesome customer service and was quick getting my policy started. Highly recommend!!

Nicole McGill was fantastic, great customer service, super quick replies and follow ups. Made everything just turn key for me and my family for closing on our new home. Thank you!

I got my car insurance for both vehicles over the phone. I spoke to Nicole Mcgrill. She was very knowledgeable and saved me $80 a month compared to my previous insurance. Very grateful for her help.

I have been insured with Choice Insurance for several years. I have auto insurance, homeowners, flood insurance and a policy on a home I rent out. Crystal Naugle always makes sure things are taken care of correctly. Great customer service!!

Having the frustration of getting a new policy Nicole McGill was professional and pleasant she put my frustrations to rest. Tried to do it on my own it wasnt working. I got the best deal with Choice Insurance it will save me a lot of money monthly thank you again.

Nicole McGill thank you so much for all your help. Your amazing!! So quick and efficient.

Have used Choice Insurance for multiple policies, for our own properties and rentals. Always responsive and helpful. Nicole McGill is fantastic and a pleasure to work with.

I was referred to Nicole McGill and could not be happier. She is VERY responsive, listened to what I needed, provided a fast quote, and got everything to my closing ahead of time. I would definitely recommend her!

Crystal was awesome, she got my FR44 done fast and proficiently. I commend you for hiring quality and professional employees!

We just bought a home and Choice Insurance was quick to give us a great rate and professional service. Nicole McGill was quick to answer any questions we had and provide great customer service.

Nicole McGill was such a pleasure to work with. She is very efficient and was looking out for our best interest. Thanks, Nicole, for such a pleasant experience purchasing our policy.

Tom Freridge is an awesome insurance broker. Generally speaking I dont like insurance folks however in this case I truly trust their advice. Tom and his team always try to do whats best for you. If the insurance Im asking for is the wrong product for our needs hell steer me in the right direction. Lastly if his insurance is not as good a deal as another companies hell let us know. I trust him with all my childrens insurance needs, college age. Thanks Choice, its nice to deal with a company that is looking out for us. Honorable. ...Steve K

Great information, looking forward to speaking with Jennifer on a rehab policy!!

I just purchased a boat and needed to hit the high seas ASAP! So after reading all of the positive reviews posted on this site, I reached out to Nicole McGill with Choice. She answered the bell with a high level of professionalism and customer service rarely seen in this profession. She asked me very detailed questions regarding my watercraft and service needs and quickly got back to me with an awesome quote..... Good by Flo, gotta go! Nicole McGill and Choice are rock stars offering over-the-top customer service and timely responsiveness.

The best process for owners

Nicole Mcgill was a pleasure to deal with. She set up my new home insurance very fast and was thorough, professional and very friendly. Always quick to respond via email, text or phone call .I highly suggest Choice Insurance Agency!

Nicole McGill gets the job done. I cant believe how easy it was working with her. Shes great and win my business. Give her a chance and she win yours!

Michelle is always helpful and awesome to talk to when I have to make updates to my policy!

I am new to Choice Insurance and Nicole McGill has been very helpful getting me started as a new customer. Great service!

Nicole McGill was a great help! She made sure I got great coverage for a great price, the process was fast and easy!

Nicole Mcgill made it so simple for my wife and I to get a new policy. Im also loving the quote. Thanks Nicole

Crystal Naugle helped me tremendously when I was in panic mode and so frustrated trying to find the best insurance for my family. I would highly recommend! Thank you Choice and Crystal!

Services and professionalism that was provided by Nicole McGill was outstanding. I have already recommended her to friends and family.

Nicole McGill gave great service! She makes insurance easy and stress free! Thank you!

We had a great experience finding insurance for an investment property with Choice Insurance. Nicole McGill took great care of us. Recoment 5 star service.

Brandy was absolutely the best...She went above and beyond to help me with all the insurance I needed... I highly recommend her . Thank You again .Linda

Found me and awesome quote, Crystal was very helpful and answered all the questions I had!

Nicole was awesome in helping me to get the insurance coverage I was looking for, in a very time efficient manner and was very professional every step of the way.

Awesome Service..... Quick quote, always willing to search for the best options....... Nicole McGill is the best.......

Nicole mcGil was super in following up on my mother in laws home way in Charlotte as if it was here in Portsmouth Va. I was very impressed. Thanks Nicole..

Crystal Naugle save me a lot of money when I switch over from my old home insurance company. Great company thanks again.

Nicole McGill made the process of getting new insurance so easy and smooth! I cannot thank her enough!

Nicole McGill, Gave such great customer service. Was very pleasant, patient, and very helpful.

Nicole McGill was very helpful and she has very good customer service skills

Nicole McGill made switching our insurance very easy !! She was very helpfull.

Nicole McGill was very easy to talk to and gave great service!

My experience with Nicole was phenomenol! She provided outstanding, honest, courteous service both yesterday while i was inquiring aboutRenters Insurance. I left a message after hours, she promptly returned my call this morning. And Yes I am abord! Nicloe also took a few extra steps, Outsanding, Excellent, Professional Customer Service.

Brandi was very helpful she found me an affordable car insurance and i will be looking to do other business with her ...Thanks Again Brandi

Nicole McGill was great, easy to get everything in place for closing on time

Nicole mcgill was amazing! awesome customer service!!

Very helpful and services were painless! Highly recommended Brandi Carr gets things done saved me money and time!

Nicole McGill was Very professional and very helpful.

Really love this place that work with me on give me time when Im late on a payment

Nicole McGill was gave a good great service for me.

Quinn is the best

Highly recommend C.A.R.R.!