Easy to deal with. Fair pricing. Quick payment.

Very professional reps who know their stuff and make selling your collection an easy and fun experience. The whole process from first contact to check in hand only took about a month for me. Highly recommended.

I recently entrusted my business with Just Collect concerning my most precious and treasured childhood possessions....cards from the 1986 Fleer Basketball set including a Michael Jordan rookie card that I have had for 35 years, and my experience with them has been nothing short of first class. I reached out to countless companies, shops, and auction houses concerning my collection, and while many were very interested, I felt the most comfortable with the guys at Just Collect. John was very helpful and easy to talk with about my collection and situation and was extremely accommodating to work with me on the option that was most comfortable for me in dealing with my collection. Leighton, the owner, met with me personally and immediately felt like a close personal friend that I had had for years, and provided me with great information and options so I could make the best decision for me personally at the time concerning my collection. If you have any old sports cards or memorabilia and are questioning potentially selling them or what to do, then please make sure you give the guys at Just Collect a call for free information, evaluations, and appraisals. They are good hearted and honest people with extensive expertise in the hobby who will take good care of you and treat you right!

These guys were great to work with from start to finish, and I didn’t even end up selling them my cards! I shipped them a batch to review and they got back to me with a fair price. I ultimately decided to try selling them on my own. So they sent them back to me on their dime. No pressure, totally professional. Highly recommend.

John at just collect was great. They were quick to get back to me and offered a fair price for my cards. They were very professional and transparent during the whole process.

John was a real pleasure to work with. He was very professional and kind. He explained the process from start to finish everything happen just like he expained. I recieved a check in the mail a few days later. I would highly recommend this company very trustworthy and excellent customer service.

Just Collect was straightforward in the transaction and that is really great. No pushing and a fair price. I sent the cards over for an evaluation, discussed the price, then the payment by check arrived a few days later. Highly recommeded.

Pleasure doing business with such honest people. Highly recommend.

Sent a request for an appraisal on 4/9/21 and never received a response. No call or email. If they are not interested, at the very minimum an email stating so would be appreciated.

Leighton is an absolute pleasure to deal with and is the most honest person you will find in this category. My dad and I have already had many positive experiences.

Sold a vintage gem 1956 Topps PSA Graded 7.5 Average . Fair and professional along the process. Shipped the cards and received payment within two days. Look forward to working with such a professional group!

Great experience selling a single graded card (Giannis Prizm rookie). They were quick to respond to my emails, and provided prompt payment exactly as they had promised!

We are completely satisfied with the honesty & good faith dealings we experienced with Just Collect Inc. As a collector of seventy years, this has been a lifetime interest & one that we take seriously. We recommend anyone interested in this field to contact this company and have faith in their fair dealings. Each item is listed separately, priced & furnished on an excel spread sheet so you can understand clearly. Excellent company.

Solid. Took the time to go over conditions and market value of my cards and were up front about what they can offer. Looking forward to selling here again in the future.

John P and the rest of the team were help professional and helpful. Not once did I feel like I was talking to a salesman, and I felt like I was talking to a trustworthy consultant. They completely went above and beyond my expectations, and I was very happy with my final offer. They cover shipping costs for both your initial evaluation and check delivery. FedEx overnight shipping for both. They are transparent with their offer prices, and compare their offer to market value. The offer price will usually be 50-70% of the market price, it may not sound like a lot, but it is very good for large collections since getting each card graded and sold on eBay etc. is very time consuming and can cost more than the cards themselves are worth. They are very responsive to emails and phone calls and I never felt pressured into selling my collection, they left it all up to me. I have a few other collections that I may sell them in the future, and they would be my go-to and recommendation to anyone looking to sell a trading card collection.

John is knowledgeable, polite, and honest...it was a pleasure working with him

I am putting 1 star for Just Collect to see this. I sent 3 emails to you guys and you guys haven´t answered, I would gladly like to put this rating up to a 5 star but i would like you guys to answer quickly

I dealt with John P. at Just Collect and he was so helpful. My cards were evaluated and appraised in a timely manner. Their response time with calls/emails was immediate. I received a very fair price for my collection and couldnt be happier. I would definitely recommend Just Collect, Inc.!! Trustworthy and fair.

I called about 1st generation Pokémon cards and I felt I wasn’t taken seriously.

We inherited an extensive collection consisting primarily of baseball cards plus some additional memorabilia. They were so helpful, educational and HONEST. When we asked why they itemized certain cards (which they bid on) and then put them back in the boxes, they responded that they didnt want to cherry pick as it would diminish the value of the collection as a whole. A pleasure to deal with, professional and highly recommend these guys.

5 stars all the way! I called Just Collect to find out information about how to sell some of my baseball cards. John P. answered and immediately gave me so much advice and his knowledge of the business is tremendous! Not only did we speak for a great length of time, but he also offered to view some of my cards to give me an idea of what to look for and walked me through a great process I can now utilize myself in the future. Excellent customer service. Most highly recommended!

What a professional experience! Just Collect did everything from the beginning that was professional and upfront. I felt very good about their process and estimate. They bought my cards and paid promptly. Very trustworthy.

Great company. Very informative. I say great because of customer service. I had a Topps 1955 card that I wanted more information on and I appreciated their speed and honesty to get back to me. Their web site was informative and one I can use as a source. Unfortunately the crease in my card brought my card way down- as expected but the truth was appreciated.

Great experience with Dave and Just Collect. He was very polite and informative as he explained the process of getting the cards appraised and determining their value. His offer was right where I expected it to be. The entire transaction was painless! I was slightly nervous about sending my cards off to someone Id only spoken with, but it was definitely worth it. Highly recommend.

My experience at Just Collect made my day. Seriously, it did!Scott & Leighton are incredibly knowledgable about cards and just all around great guys. I found Just Collect on Google and gave them a call to inquire about my collection. They were always patient with my questions and quick to respond.After our phone call I decided to make the drive to visit and get an appraisal on my cards. This was the fun part! I understood that these cards had sentimental value but Scott & Leighton truly made me feel a connection to the collection. They were extremely transparent about pricing and made me a very fair offer which was actually higher than I had expected.I would recommend Just Collect to anyone that wants to sell their card collection to a knowledgeable and honest company. But also to anyone that wants to have a great experience. Like I said, my time at Just Collect was the highlight of my day and gave me a true appreciation for the cards that I had.

I recently contacted their company regarding a rare unopened 2000 football box I wanted to sell. Initially my inquiry was received very well. I was told they were interested in making me an offer. After waiting a week I never received a response. When I contacted them back I was apologized to but told they no longer wanted the box nor did I receive any type of offer. They merely directed me to try and sell my rare item on eBay or at an auction house. This was not the service I expected especially since their website states, “We are the nation’s top buyer of vintage sports cards and memorabilia.” Apparently their claim is exaggerated and unfounded. Their service was nothing more than a waste of time for me. I just love the owners response now. Initially he posted that I requested $13,000 for the box. That was until I posted all the dialogue between his employee and myself exposing him for the actual truth. It would be nice if a business just gave you an honest answer from the start instead of fabricating a story to protect themselves.

I had a vintage baseball card that I was interested in selling. After doing some research and contacting several potential buyers, I chose Just Collect. I sent them information and they responded immediately. I talked with John Palomares and received great information and details on how to send the card for evaluation. They were very upfront and honest about the card I sent and I was very pleased with the offer they made me. They were prompt in their settlement and I HIGHLY recommend doing business with them. Thank you John and Just Collect, it has been a pleasure doing business with you. Wayne

My experience with Just Collect was better than I anticipated. After contacting, receiving an appraisal, we met and were able to make a deal. Just Collect is the most professional outfit that I have ever dealt with. I highly recommend Just Collect. Dealing with Scott was an enjoyable experience.

My experience with Just Collect was good in all respects. Although I had hung on to my old baseball cards for over 50 years, parting with them was made easy with the help of both John and Scott from Just Collect. I was especially grateful for being able to use their FedEx account to send and insure my collection. Having had some negative experiences with other dealers in the past I am elated to have found Just Collect and would highly recommend them to anyone seeking to sell their collection.

What seemed at first like a difficult task in terms of parting with my treasured collection and making sure I received what it was worth was made easy by dealing with John at Just Collect. He was easy to talk to and readily available to answer all my concerns. In the end, all parties were happy and satisfied.

Wonderful service with fair and transparent valuations. Founder Leighton Sheldon started collecting sports cards at age 8 and has never stopped building his knowledge and passion for American sports memorabilia. He and his team run a very professional operation and bring a warm personal touch. I highly recommend Just Collect for buying and selling sports cards.

Just Collect embodies professionalism. From my interactions with John, Who always answered all my questions to the owner himself Leighton who took the time to meet with us and explain the condition and value of my baseball cards, He gave me a fair offer, without any pressure to sell if I chose not to. Thank you John and Leighton for such wonderful service. I highly recommend Just Collect. Top Notch all the way!!

I had a fantastic experience selling my 50 yo card collection to Just Collect. John P. responded promptly to all my questions. I believe I got a fair offer for my cards.

John at Just Collect made the process of selling my collection very smooth. He responded to my initial inquiry promptly and answered all my questions, assuring me that my cards would be treated with care and respect. I received a fair offer and a check delivered in two days as promised. Everything was handled very professionally and with personal attention.

John with Just Collect worked with me on a deal to buy my 1961 Fleer Basketball cards and was fantastic to work with. From the time he provided the FedEx shipping information so I could mail the cards, to the time we agreed on a price, it was a very positive and professional experience. Would highly recommend doing business with Just Collect.

Went today and they honestly took a lot of time going through my cards. Everyone was very nice. I left very satisfied with what they offered me for my collection. I will definitely be returning.

They were excellent in assisting me on the phone with my jordan cards and spent time explaining everything to me as well. Great experience wish I had that with every company you try to contact. Thanks again you guys rock!!!!

Very professional. No pressure. Very knowledgeable. Fair pricing. Overall a very good experience.

They say, Three times a charm. For me that saying holds true. I was finally able to get the fairest price for my Goudey Baseball Cards from Just Collect after trying two other dealers!

I had these baseball cards from my late husband and didn’t know where to sell them. With Google’s help, I came across Just Collect, inc. I called their phone number and was given instructions of how to email them. Then began my relationship with John P. With his guidance, it couldn’t have been easier. The staff was even willing to travel to view my collection. I must admit there was some trepidation as I didn’t want to be scammed. John answered all my questions and assured me that my collection was worthwhile. We finally agreed that I would send the collection to them with shipping and insurance costs paid by Just Collect. The whole process took a little over three weeks and I couldn’t have been more pleased with our negotiations. John was very professional. Thank you.

It was a delight working with Just Collect--professional, prompt responses and kind interactions. I will recommend them to family and friends.

John was super helpful, insightful and knowledgeable concerning the questions I had about my vintage card collection. If you have any questions or need advice I highly recommended giving Just Collect a call or sending them an email.

Made the whole process really simple and clear. Wasnt sure what to expect, but John was great to work with! Recommend them!

I recently called and spoke with John about my baseball card collection. He was very helpful and provided some great advice. Glad I contacted Just Collect.

These folks did right by me. Very happy with their appraisal and their offer. Nice to find reputable service like this on the InterWebs.

I had over 400 trading cards from the early 60s, baseball, football and non sport cards and didnt know what to do. I contacted Just Collect and spoke to John. He talked me thru the process and I felt very comfortable to send them my cards and have them evaluated. I sent away and John kept me updated when received and when evaluated. Once they made me an offer John and I went thru their offer and made a couple adjustments and came to a fair price to me.I was very satisfied with Just Collect as to there knowledge and the way they dealt with me, very professional....Thank You John and Just Collect for making this transaction go very smoothly.Steve

We found Just Collect and Leighton through an internet search. Just Collects website is professional, but somehow comfortable and inviting - like hanging out with a friend kind of inviting. We met with Leighton to talk about my husbands childhood collection of baseball cards. Leightons enthusiasm about collecting and his very apparent knowledge was refreshing. We knew we had made the right choice to contact him at Just Collect. His appraisal of our cards was honest and fair and yes, fun! We highly recommend Leighton!

I contacted Just Collect to sell my collection of primarily 1970s sports cards via their web form. Within an hour, I received a call to set up an appointment with Leighton Sheldon at the Philly Show in Valley Forge, Pennsylvania. I collected as a kid and the cards had been stored in my moms attic for the past 25 years. I associate the collection with her taking me and my brother to card shows, card stores, and flea markets. I had a few cards graded (a PSA6 Nolan Ryan rookie, PSA8 Joe Montana rookie), but the majority were raw and not in the best condition. Leighton took the time to review and appraise my collection and explain how he came up with his offer. It was a fair price given the condition of the cards and I couldnt have been happier. He paid me cash on the spot - which I didnt expect; the entire meeting took about an hour. Even though my collection was not high-grade or rare, Leighton treated me with respect and was honest in his appraisal. It was a great experience and I would recommend Just Collect to anyone looking to sell their vintage material.-Roger

Just Collect had immeasurable expertise and knowledge when I sent in a query about an autographed baseball. The response time was quick and the answers solid.

Its been a long seven years of research on a collection of cards that Ive inherited. I called John Palomares and from DAY ONE, hes been the most courteous and more helpful than ANYONE else Ive spoken with in the industry. Hes honest, upfront, and hes even gone through the trouble of mailing me some card cases without charge to help me with these sets. After all these years, I feel bad not doing a transaction with him but Ive actually found a local buyer who will save me the trouble of flying or mailing these cards from Hawaii to a buyer on the mainland. John actually gave me precautions on what to look for when selling to ANYONE. Excellent service and sincere kindness in looking out for the best for me.Thank you John and JustCollect for your awesome service!!!

Professional and willing to take the time to help you

John Palomares and Just Collect are the epitome of professionalism.The cards were shipped via insured FedEx no cost to me, and three days later John made me a very fair offer to purchase the cards. Just Collect and John Palomares have my absolute recommendation. Totally professional, honest and forthright.

Scott and team were great to deal with and were very fair in grading my collection. I highly recommend them!

The whole experience of selling my collection went smoother than I had expected. Sent collection in and received check shortly thereafter.

John was very helpful, quick and easy to work with!

When my grandfather passed away we have been collecting cards our whole lives i just couldnt do it with out him i thought it was going to be a nightmare to sell them in till i came across john and the rest of the just collect family who were kind and curtious shipped my cards to them three days later they sent a check if you have cards to sell just collectis the place to do it

I wasted an entire day driving to their warehouse in NJ, after hours of calculating the value, an insulting and unworthy offer was made. Dont expect more than 25% of worth for your card collection. I call it like I see it...and this place is a sham!

Great service!

Very professional!