Absolutely fantastic Italian restaurant. The food was exceptional, the service was great and the price was well worth the the experience. The atmosphere was nice with very low lit seeing. Perhaps a little too low? But Im not complaining at all. If youre in the area and looking for a good meal I highly recommend Pasatrrific.

This place has really cool decor and great ambiance. We had a nice and friendly waitress but surprisingly she hadnt tried many of the dishes. This could be an issue with the restaurant rules as she said they do not give staff any discounts for food, not allowing them to try all the dishes. There are many options even if Italian food is not your favorite. The food was really good but could have been warmer when it got to us. Prices are $$-$$$. I recommend trying Pastarrific if you like/love Italian food.

Our family was there July 17, 2021. It was Saturday around 5pm. I have to say that, across the board, it was the best meal we have ever had at your restaurant. Six adults, 3 kids (one in a high chair) and we were all treated with the utmost respect and patience. Our waiter (unfortunately, I do not remember his name) was top notch making sure we had everything we needed and more. The food was excellent and came to the table piping hot and delicious. We’ll be back, for sure.

My favorite Italian place in Kokomo. Hands down the best bread sticks youll ever have.

The asiago chicken penne was great! Waited for bread and oil, yet once it arrived it was warm and delicious!

By far the nastiest food I’ve ever eaten. This place use to be excellent. Definitely putting on my never eat there again list. 🤢

Waiter wasnt the best. I understand the staff issues, so Ill give them another try. Food was par and I couldve done better on my grill at home. Great atmosphere. Just remember that you can have a completely different experience.

This place is fabulous!! Place is always clean waiters and waitresses are extremely friendly and food is fantastic never had a problem with food and they dont rush you to make a order.... just wished I wasnt so full I would have gotten a dessert but the birthday main course was plenty had no room for the dessert! Well definitely go back again!. Keep up the great work PASTArrific!!

The service and food are consistently excellent. The number of lasagna options is out of this world. You really cant go wrong with whatever you choose. Highly recommend.

They have improved the atmosphere since we were there. It was a pleasant experience. The food is top notch. I had lasagna. It is the best anyplace around.

Service was great. Had a little wait for food but it was well worth it. Very clean restaurant.

The spinach Lasagna is absolutely delicious and the bread sticks with the oil sauce is always yummy. This is a wonderful place that we have enjoyed for years and have enjoyed all of the dishes that we have tried.

Great Customer Service Great Food And Drink

Prices okay. Food was great. Not a good good place for pizza. Service the waiter was not very on top of things and more into by boyfriend than his tables. Management didnt even know what was going on took over an hour to get good.

Great atmosphere and food. Allison was a great waitress.

Excellent food and environment. Havent been since the fire.... beautiful new dining area and again food was awesome!

This was a very positive dining experience on a Mothers Day. The staff was extremely attentive and our waitress Lacey was just over the top! Very professional very personable. We will be back again

One of the poorest dining experiences Ive had. Ive eaten here before and the food is delicious and the staff was very efficient. However, tonight was a totally different story. Called ahead to see how long the wait was and the hostesses said 35 minutes. We waited over an hour and a half. Placed our drink order, ten minutes later placed our food order. Three separate orders of bread sticks(bc the food was taking so long) and 43 minutes later I asked them to box up our order to go. Fifteen minutes later our boxed food came out. Our poor waitress was so embarrassed and apologetic. I spoke to the manager and all he could say was Its been a crazy week. Ill have to get on the kitchen staff. If I had wanted unlimited bread sticks and salad for dinner I would have gone to the other Italian restaurant.Wont go back...no matter how good the food is.

Great atmosphere. Server was very nice. Food was really good. I would recommend.

Twice I have ordered the Penne Mediterranean Chicken and the chicken is very very dry.

Very good. No problems. Great service.

Food wasnt the best and the drinks were easy to strong. Service was decent.

We just went for carryout breadsticks and salad, but the lady up front was very nice and helpful. Place was beautiful inside, however, almost wish we would’ve stayed!

GREAT food, although we had to send a couple breadsticks bsck because they were frozen. in their defense they were absolutely hammered at the time and understaffed

Best Italian food Ive found in Northern Indiana. Such friendly staff who gave the perfect recommendations. Their bruschetta its top notch. We all loved our dishes from the seafood pasta to the ribeye steak. I loved my pasta with steak tips. Favorite drink of the night was the raspberry lemon drop.

Husband and I ate dinner here for his birthday dinner. It was decent food, but I didnt think it was as good as my husband did. We both got chicken Parmesan and our waitress was on top of it! 4/5 for the food, but 5/5 for the service and ambiance.

There was a wait but well worth the wait great pasta, salad and breadsticks

Theyve done some work on the menu and added some great stuff, and the original menu content seems to have improved since they first moved into the new building. Its one of our favorite places to eat in Kokomo, though there is little that is light in the menu those choices have improved as well. Their wine selection is also great. Makes a wonderful date night location without going too far from home, or a family dinner out. Cant recommend it enough.

The atmosphere is gorgeous inside! The food is so tasty, I highly recommend the steak and mushroom risotto or the veggie risotto 😋

Excellent service! Awesome food & atmosphere.

Great food! Friendly staff. We get the take out 9x11 pans of pasta. Might seem expensive up front but its leftovers for a few days. So its cost effective.

It honestly wasn’t great. It’s the furthest from Italian that you can have. Service was great and super nice, so that’s a good point. But food was just meh. My traditional lasagna was made of sausage instead of ground meat. In Italy, or Europe, or everywhere else than This place, traditional lasagna is made of ground beef (with or without pork). So it was utterly disappointing. Breadsticks were also meh. Very much dry and missing fluff. Alfredo sauce was too salty. The highlight was the tomato mozzarella and the service that was perfect.

Jasmine was an excellent server! Lunch time was very busy; but, Chef Cynthia was bringing out freshly baked bread sticks while we were waiting! Lunch was scrumptious!

Remember when this place burned to a crisp like a crispy shrimp?Mac & Laura had their rehearsal dinner here. Do you remember that? It was before the crispy shrimp thing.They used to have a penne dish that was really good. I think it had chicken in it. I bet you could get it with crispy shrimps.

We met with friends in the bistro side. The food was tasty, the service attentive, and the atmosphere about what you would expect in a sports bar. Next year (since we only get to Kokomo annually), were going to try the restaurant.

Service was extremely poor at lunch time! There were only 4 other people there at a booth and waitress sat us by kitchen. We both mentioned it was very dark, even though it was lunch time, and we could not see the menus and that there are overhead lighting at other rows of booths that were empty. However, instead of moving us she lit a candle on the table and said this wont help much. Then she took over 15 minutes to check if I could add chicken to dish I ordered...then another 20-25 minutes or so for food. She never came back to our table to check on us or if wed like anything else. We had to ask another waitress to please go find her. We had to ask for refill on drinks, then for our to go boxes and finally to please split the check. We have eaten here numerous times when the place was very busy at lunch with no difficulties. Hoping this is just a waitress having a bad day.

Amazing food!! Great service & ambiance 🥰🥰

We had a nice meal. Portion size was nice, good flavor.

I had the Veal Marsala and it was to die for. Bridget; our server was amazing too. We were there for our girls night out holiday gathering. We all have adopted Bridget bcs of her great personality and we all just fell in love with her. We had the manager take a picture of us and Bridget as well. Everything was amazing.

Food was good. I just prefer the items at Olive Garden. Service was great. It wasnt too busy. The wife likes eating here, so we eat here more often than I would normally. Worth trying if you like Italian, my preference for OG may not be yours.

Delicious food and great service!

Incredibly beautiful décor since upgrade after the rebuild and the food was fantastic.... service outstanding! This Kokomo owned small business is the Crown jewel of fine, but affordable dining. 5 Stars!

Great food. Great service

If you ever wondered what it would be like to visit an Italian restaurant on the Death Star, this is your place. I ate here a couple of times before the fire and felt the decor was dated, the atmosphere stale and the food just meh. Stepping off the turbo lift into the new and improved Pastarrific I was impressed. The decor is bright, modern and inspired. Make no mistake, there is not much to allude that you are in an Italian restaurant save some pictures on the wall and that is perfectly fine. We had reservations and were seated as soon as we arrived. Our server, Bridget, was very good; she was prompt and attentive. Hoping the food was on par with the new look, I was not disappointed. We started with the baked spinach dip and breadsticks. I highly recommend getting a side of marinara, it is one of the best tasting marinara I have had in a long time. For my entree, I had the seafood Alfredo and although it was a bit heavy on the sauce it was still very good as was the the Bloody Mary. I feel this is the best Italian you can get in Kokomo.

Excellent food and service. Price was just slightly high. Look like a great place to take a group

Great place awesome service!

I have only done carry out since the remodel. We went in once and it was very loud and all out in the open. I enjoyed the old layout, with booths. The food is still good, but has increased the prices.

It was wonderful I thank you for hiring me

I called in my order at 7 and was told it would take 40 mins. It actually took 65 mins. I should have checked my order before I drove away. Big mistake. They shorted me a salad and breadsticks. Ill never be back.

Was a fantastic meal the name says it all pastarrific indeed will definitely return

Might not have been bad, but the waitress disappeared, so that meant no refills, bread or to let her know that there was hair in the pasta

Very good food and service

Went during covid, looking for a nice night out. No social distancing. Order I received was incorrect. Waitress seemed overwhelmed so we didnt see her much. Nice ambience but I dont think well be back.

We were going to Kokomo to see my fiancés dad and step mom. Wanted to go out to eat and I felt like pasta. My fiancé asked if I had ever been here and I said no. His step mom said she hadnt heard very good things since it was re-built. We were skeptical but after seeing 4.3 stars, we decided to try anyways. And I am SO GLAD we did. We usually try to get Calamari when places have it. The last few places we tried it was a bit chewy, not great. The calamari here, SPOT ON. Cooked perfect and the sauce was also perfect. We took quite a bit of food home. I just ate my soup. Some sort of potato soup 4 days later and OMG. So delicious! Our service was great. We went on a Sunday evening, and sat in the bar. Not sure if that was the difference in the service but we will DEFINITELY be back.

Too dark to read the menu. Food was good but not great. Service great.

Kinda high for pasta if you ask me.

The service was not good..not friendly.the time to be waited on was ridiculous and waited to get food..was not a pleasant experience..not sure if we will go back

Great food and super polite servers. Will definitely return.

Server had too many tables...couldnt keep up with drink refills. Order of fish was miserably small for $15. NOT kid friendly and too dark to see my menu.

Favorite Italian restaurant. Chefs Special is truly awesome.

Ehhh not that good of quality nor taste, thought maybe I went too late in the night, doubled back the next day, same thing; honestly -fazolis is better believe it or not lol

Good food. Very dark inside

Good food and friendly service.

Great food and decent prices. The chicken parmigiana was great! Service was good too on a Sunday afternoon.

Was craving Chicken and Noodles but not on menu anymore. :(

Chef Boy Ardee has better spaghetti, breadsticks were doughy and unflavored.Almost nothing came as it was ordered and when we finally got it, it was near an hour after ordered.Wont be returning.

Waitress was awesome and the food was great

Great food, good atmosphere family friendly

Much better than last time. Had chicken piccata. Chicken was cooked well. Not dry like last time. Seems like they have decided to be an Italian restaurant. Decor has changed. Atmosphere was pleasant. Had some identity issues at first in new bldg. Looks like they may have worked them out.

Amazing food and beer. The waitress was super nice and brought a beer sample over without me asking. Great service and will definitely go back!

Great place. I got their lasagna sampler all 3 were great. My wife got their shrimp with vodka sauce. We brought home our leftovers and enjoyed them the next day.

Excellent food and service

Great service great food really Nice relaxing atmosphere

Great service! Great food!

Had reservations and still waited 30 mins... service was not satisfactory.

Everything was great as always

Fantastic food and the staff is absolutely lovely!

Cold Beer, Great Food, Friendly Staff. Best Tomato Basil Soup anywhere

The food was delicious and the service was amazing. Definitely will be back.

Food wasnt bad. the chicken and fish were dry and found a bone in my fish. Thought the food could have been better. Service was great!

Very good experience! They were fast, and courteous. The food was Awesome! My drinks did seem a bit short, but after two. I seen why they were potent! Great place for one or your whole family.

Nice outside patio area. Lots of good choices. Food that you cant find other places. Waiter was accommodating.Nice outside

Very nice space. Ate in the separate room and was given a vegan option. Taste superb.

Dont skip dessert here! The brown cow cheesecake, the chocolate cake, or the limoncello cake are all great choices! The peach sangria is to die for!

Just picked up a Drive-thru Togo order of baked spaghetti, It was great! To start off the service was fast, my first bite you can taste the freshness! My favorite was the fresh topping of melted cheese! Couldnt get enough! Definitely recommending this menu item!

Food and people were great! They just need to turn the lights up so you do not need a flashlight to read the menu.

Great pasta, homemade breadsticks, salads, and more. Friendly service.

Delicious 😋

Just a nice place to eat. Very friendly, good food. Don’t be in a rush take friend with you. We have groups of 10-15 and always satisfied. Fair fair price

Was told by others that the food wasnt as good since the reopen. This was my first time there since the opening and they were right. Appetizers wasnt good at all. I had chicken and noodles, mashed potatoes and green beans. Mashed potatoes were okay. Only had a bite of green beans. (Straight out of the can no spices or anything) chicken and noodles were just okay. Needless to say I didnt take home any of my leftovers and I had plenty. Good service.The waitress was very nice. Wont be going back again. Really sad. My daughter had the eggplant and liked it. Thats why I rated the 3 instead of a 2.

Breadsticks with olive oil were good. My crispy chicken salad had cold crispy chicken. Would have been better hot so I will have to specify that if I go back. The other dish was the pasta with grilled chicken and a salad. I was told that it was good.

This has been one of my favorite places to go to with my family since we personally know the owners. Beautiful restaurant!!! Food and atmosphere are amazing! Will have to take my fiancé here sometime since I tell him all about it. Definitely a go to place for some good Italian.

First time going after the rebuild. Interior is beautiful. Our waitress was excellent and let us take our time to order without being pressured. She had great recommendation for appetizer. I had the bruschetta and it was delicious!!

Fantastic food and lovely bartender last night. Definitely recommend.

Always tasty with good service

Beautiful restaurant, clean, experienced wait staff and a fabulous menu. My favorite is the meat lasagna, salad and bread, my husband loves everything.I love that if Im too lazy to cook I can call in my order and pick up our dinner at their convenient drive-through pick-up window around back.Highly recommend.

Great atmosphere, food and service were great, best breadsticks ever. 13 avg entre. We will be back

Started off a little rough. We had a bigger party. The first server got overwhelmed so she was replaced and the second server was very attentive. Very good server.

This is one of the best Italian restaurant you can find in Indiana. I had seafood Alfredo, and someone with me had white lasagna. I was very impressed - good entrees, superb delicious! I had excellent server that evening too, good reasons to visit back when Im in town.P.S. When you are done eating, whats awesome about this restaurant is that they have mouthwash that you can rinse in the bathroom. Now thats impressive restaurant !!

I really enjoy the atmosphere of this locally owned, Italian eatery. The food is also delicious. My one issue is with the servers who are often inattentive and lack a sense of urgency.