What a wonderful action house!!! They have such an outstanding staff!!! Mr. and Mrs. Bodnar treat you like you are part of their family! The merchandise is out of this world. They always have something for everyone! They focus on quality and they go above all expectations to provide an excellent buying and selling experience! I would give this auction house Infinite stars if I could!!

Fantastic! I have bought and sold many items over the years, including on the current online-only platform.Joe and Maureen and the entire staff are very friendly, professional, honest, and treat both you and your treasures with great respect when your are selling.Highly recommend them whether you are searching for some new treasures or editing down what you have.Every auction has something for everybody.Outstanding.

Bad packaging with broken pieces, Bodnars does not assume its responsibility for not paying. Terrible treatment and poor service, using subterfuge not to pay, asking for a non-restorable certification from a certified restorer, when just seeing the piece is enough. And it was not because of mistreatment in shipping, but because of bad packaging from Bodnars.

I have nothing but great things to say about Bodnars Auctions. They have always been speedy with delivery, very honest with the bids, and I have never had an issue with quality of the item I buy. I buy a lot of Comics from them which it is hard to tell online sometimes, and the quality is always a high grade. They are descriptive with their items, so you always know what you are going to get. Even though I wish they would do in person events again at the NJ Convention Center, I will be a customer of there for a long time.

This place makes me money I loved coming here if you see me don’t bid against me I always win 🤣 it’s a great time and a lot of cool things I didn’t want to give a review because I want to push buyers away so I have more inventory lol here some pictures

Wow, i had an amazing experience, I have bought from other Auctioneers over the past and has been nothing but a disaster. I saw some items again on bodnar auctions and took another shot. I have to say i was very impressed with the way things were ran,. I love the live auction (it was fun) the customer service before and after was on key. Very happy with experience.i I was greeted with a friendly face when i picked up. There was no Hassles or surprises. I am very happy with my newfound treasures. And would definitely refer all my friends to bodnars auctions-and will be definitely be checking the next auctions thanks again Bodnars!!

If you are buying online with shipping Beware it will cost you at this place, will not buy here again.

Above and beyond the worst customer support from anyone ever let alone the owners Joseph Bodnar and his wife. Waited over 2 weeks after item was paid before I received a shipping invoice for $55 for legos. Was informed to pay the shipping or I would not get the items or a refund on my items from the owner. 100% a scam

Bodnars has been wonderful to me! I have been cleaning out my house and any items I want to sell they have taken and gotten a fair price for me. They honest and caring! Im happy to do Business with them!

NEVER USE THIS PLACEThis place scams people and prays on people

Fun auctions, got some great stuff cheap. Only drawback is I think Im a hoarder now.

Unprepared group that offers services to their customers like telephone bids and absentee bidders and are not able to perform. Randomly cancels this service. Key personnel do not know how to offer the services they list. Key personnel show up 15 minutes before auction starts and cancel services. Pictures of auction not posted until very LATE the night before. No way to reference items for sale even if they did accept absentee bids. As a buyer, I can always go somewhere else. The poor owners commit their items to a group that is ill equipped to get them the best price for their things. Does not even deserve one star.

Best auction around. Wish they were more than just once a month.

As I said once before, Wonderful People Work here. Thanks too all for your constant help. One Huge Look Auction!👍👍👍👍👍

Love this service! Great deals if you know what to look for!

Never return phone call and brag about how good they are, call them first if you want to waste your call.

Great place, sort of.

Great deals and great company

Had a terrible experience with a nasty female auctioneer there in the past. I think she is finally gone. Auctioneers shouldnt compete with buyers.

5 starts